UCAN Philippines Catholic Church News
Happy Easter to all

What the Pope can pray for

February 22, 2013
What the Pope can pray for thumbnail

In the twelve days since Benedict XVI announced his retirement, I’ve been wondering whether the Church of Rome might not have been better served—at least from the point of view of progressive Catholics—by the Pope keeping his job and drawing an eventual last breath, in what he would call God’s time, on Peter’s throne. It would have released those Catholics from the strictures of empathy, admiration, and grueling patience his voluntary leaving seems to have placed upon them. (St. Peter, by the way, was married.)

The response has been uncharacteristically kind. And how could it not be, at the shock of such eloquent and simple humility coming from the man who, for the past thirty-two years, enforced and eventually led the doctrinal retreat into the Middle Ages begun by his predecessor.

There have been endless comparisons between the style of Benedict’s departure and that of John Paul II, in 2005; they are almost comically stereotypic: Pope John Paul II’s ardent, emotional, and pointedly public ecce-homo calvary through disease, senility, and incapacity to death; and Benedict’s rational, considered decision, clearing the way for a like-minded successor who would presumably restore obedience and fealty to a Church whose authority, like his own, was waning. “For the good of the Church,” is how Benedict described his resignation. It may be that, however weakened, Benedict was crafty.

There have been many theories, though few, to my knowledge, say that Joseph Aloisius Ratzinger was pushed into retirement, let alone that those honest, eloquent words about no longer possessing the quality of mind and body that the papacy requires had been scripted for him. And with good reason: knowing Benedict, he probably pushed himself. Today, the average age of the Church’s cardinals, who will convene next week to begin considering candidates for the next pope, is seventy-two, and those who are under eighty—the only ones eligible to actually cast ballots in a papal conclave—were all appointed by John Paul II or, more often than not, by Benedict XVI.

So it’s safe to say that the College of Cardinals has been stacked to ensure that their linea gotica continues moving backward. And never mind that the Church has been losing both priests and nuns because of a doctrine of celibacy that began not in the Gospels but in the fourth century (and was largely ignored until much later); because of a doctrine of infallibility that in fact only became canonic in 1870; and because of an institutionalized misogyny that has not only kept women from the priesthood but sends them to Hell if they drop by Planned Parenthood for a morning-after pill, or even if, like those valiant American “nuns on the bus,” they drive off without permission to minister to the poor. The list goes on.

A new face, with a new infallibility chakra under his papal hat, may be the Church’s last best hope for what is now called “putting the past behind us”—“the past,” in this case, including decades of rampant, officially closeted pedophilia, involving thousands of priests preying on tens of thousands of children—and continuing its long march backward. [More]


New Yorker

stay in touch
Subscribe to UCAN Philippines
Free newsletter here
Invite a Friend
top stories
  1. about us - 15 emails
  2. Who is a Roman Catholic? - 10 emails
  3. Creation not man’s property, pope says as Advent begins - 7 emails
  4. Pacquiao plans ‘preaching session’ after fight - 7 emails
  5. Bishop accused of diverting millions - 7 emails
  6. Priest backs Filipina’s bid in ‘American Idol’ - 6 emails
  7. Tagle says Church needs to be rescued from self-interest - 6 emails
  8. ‘Weeping’ Mary draws hundreds to Windsor residence - 5 emails
  9. Porn documentary to show at World Youth Day - 5 emails
  10. Exorcism is God’s gift ‘to help us believe’ - 5 emails
  1. Why do some Catholics dislike Pope Francis washing feet?
  2. Bishops and the environment
  3. Philippines bishops call on Catholics to diet and exercise
  4. Philippine greens slam 'US militarism' on Earth Day
  5. Gunmen kill Philippine mayor and bodyguards
  6. Philippines press club demands media workers protection
  7. Philippines bishops say typhoon victims still need urgent aid
  8. Wanted: new ways to seek justice for Philippines tribals
  9. Philippine bishops warn against self-flagellation
  10. Philippine organic farmers urge end to GMO rice
  1. Philippine green group warns of lead in John Paul II statues
  2. Wanted: new ways to seek justice for Philippines tribals
  3. Philippine organic farmers urge end to GMO rice
  4. Questions raised over speed of papal canonizations
  5. Bishops and the environment
  6. Why do some Catholics dislike Pope Francis washing feet?
  7. Philippine greens slam ‘US militarism’ on Earth Day
  8. China set to be ‘world’s most Christian country’ by 2030
  9. Gunmen kill Philippine mayor and bodyguards
  10. Boat capsizes during Indonesian Holy Week procession
  1. On September 20, speaking to a gathering of gynecologists, Pope Francis said: "E...
    Said FrSeanCoyle on 2013-10-09 16:05:00
  2. Here is what Pope Benedict said to the bishops of Switzerland on November 9, 200...
    Said FrSeanCoyle on 2013-10-09 16:02:00
  3. stop RHbill for Gods sake!!!...
    Said joy on 2013-07-17 20:03:00
  4. a woman who agree this RH bill has no heart. God forgive her she do'nt know what...
    Said joy on 2013-07-17 20:02:00
  5. It is very hard to trust a muslim. They worship a false god and will break the ...
    Said on 2013-07-17 12:23:00
  6. Assuredly, thus said the LORD GOD ALMIGHTY YISRAEL to Roman Christian Catholic B...
    Said Angel Santie on 2013-06-28 19:39:00
  7. God let man or as we say permit man to create this way of comunication, why we w...
    Said joy on 2013-06-26 20:46:00
  8. Pray for the victims of clergy sexual abuse....
    Said on 2013-06-06 08:01:00
  9. 'Activist priest Robert Reyes is in the minority among the clergy when it comes ...
    Said on 2013-04-24 15:04:00
  10. 90-year-old Fr Emmanuel Non SJ had a letter in last Monday's Philippine Daily In...
    Said on 2013-04-18 10:41:00
UCAN India Books Online